Planning
Tax-loss harvesting, without the folklore
What realizing a loss does, where it is denied, and why a same-day repurchase is not a universal trick.
7 min read · Updated Nov 16, 2026
The idea
Tax-loss harvesting means selling an asset that is worth less than it cost, so the loss can offset gains, and sometimes a slice of other income. You then decide whether to stay out, or to buy the asset back and start a new holding period. It is ordinary portfolio maintenance in realization systems. It is not a shelter, and it is not available everywhere.
Where the loss is real
- United States: capital losses offset capital gains. Up to $3,000 of net loss offsets ordinary income. The rest carries forward. A sale to yourself, or a sale that the wash-sale rule covers, does not count.
- United Kingdom: losses offset gains. The 30-day bed-and-breakfast rule matches a repurchase to the sale, so an immediate rebuy denies the loss you were counting on.
- Canada: the superficial-loss rule denies a loss if you or an affiliated person reacquires the same property within 30 days and still holds it at the end of that window.
- Germany: private-sale losses generally offset private-sale gains, not salary. After the one-year holding period there is often no taxable gain to harvest against, and no loss either.
- India: a virtual-digital-asset loss cannot offset other income and cannot be carried forward. Harvesting does not work.
The US wash-sale point, stated carefully
The wash-sale statute is written for stock and securities. The IRS has not issued a ruling that applies it, in those words, to every crypto asset. Congress has considered amending it. A sale and an immediate repurchase of bitcoin is therefore not something this site will call either “clearly fine” or “clearly a wash sale.” Economic substance, the related-party rules, and a possible statutory change are all live. If the amounts matter, this is a question for a preparer reading the year you sell, not for a general article.
The UK rule does not have that ambiguity. The 30-day rule applies to cryptoassets. Plan accordingly, or rather, do not plan a same-week rebuy and expect the loss to survive.
What not to do
Do not manufacture losses with a counterparty who is you, your company, or a relative, and expect a system with related-party rules to respect them. Do not ignore the new, higher basis if you do rebuy: the loss you claimed is the reason the next gain will be larger. Do not harvest in a country that will not use the loss. And do not treat a scam, a forgotten password, or a collapsed exchange as an automatic capital loss. Those have their own, narrower paths.